Victoria Justice

Naomi Mills

Pierson Fodé

Ely Diamond

Matthew Daddario

Gabriel

Ryan Ward

Bruce 2

Griffin Newman

Bruce 1

Monique Coleman

Girl-Robin

Danny Flaherty

Boy-Robin

Gary Betsworth

Mr. McAllister

Dean Kapica

George

Marianne Hagan

Mom-Susan

Maddie Corman

Mom-Ginny

Petronia Paley

Mrs. Loy

Kathy Tong

Cassandra

Kevin Abernethy

Club Goer

Connor Antico

Dude is Boxer

Ali Skye Bennet

Carrie Wannabe

Charles Cain

Young Ely

AJ Cedeno

Barista

Spike Christie

Naomi's Dad

Michael DeMello

Bouncer

David Eggers II

College Student

Olamide Faison

Otis

Najee Griffin

Basketball Player

Miki Hanta

Stir Fry Girl

Cindy Ho

Party Girl

Kevin Ho

College Student

Lily James

Young Naomi

Salma Khan

College Student

Tural Manafov

Club Goer

Gianna Marino

Party Goer

Juliette Marotta

Wedding Guest

Shane Mehigan

Basketball Player / Party DJ

Kurt Meier

Teen Ely

Heather Merkel

Young Mother

Makayla Merkel

Young Daughter

Roy Nowlin

Wedding Guest

Dorsea Palmer

Rich Kid

Jillian Pedone

Teen Naomi

Doug Plaut

R.A.

Portia

Professor

Robyn Pugh

Coffee Shop Patron

Madison Riley

Dakota

Sergi Robles

Teacher's Assistant

Jacinto Romero

Afro Guy

Kristen Romond

Wedding Guest

Michael Ruggiere

Water Balloon Guy

Lucas Saiter

I.A.Y.B. Guy

Cliff Samara

Mahmood

Jason B. Schmidt

Very Gay Guy

Casey Smith

Stoner

Eshita Starr

Bakery Customer / Party Girl / Student

Will Torres

Karaoke bar patron

Tashiana Washington

Tennesse

Roger Yeh

Geeky Guy

Benjamin Eakeley

Wanker Banker

Alanna Fox

Cheesy Girl

Andi Matichak

Montana

Kristin Hanggi

Director

Amy Andelson

Screenplay

Emily Meyer

Screenplay

Rachel Cohn

Novel

David Levithan

Novel

Michelle Harrison

Editor

Anka Malatynska

Director of Photography

Dara Wishingrad

Production Design

Alexandra Milchan

Producer

Cassian Elwes

Executive Producer

Deborah Lurie

Original Music Composer